** This thread discusses the content article: Porcupine Tree - The Incident **

Good start Aditya. I've tried three times but still haven't been able to go past the first few songs. A pretty disjointed effort that does have a few cool parts.

Terrific review - and very satisfyingly verbose *-) I didn't have as many problems with the album per se (other than the triteness of the lyrics. Time Flies? Really now!). It did sound like the new Paradise Lost — more of a hard-working album than a genuinely good one. An album where the band members struggled to make songs 'interesting.' Having said that, I consider both albums fairly worthwhile. I'd have given this a more average 2.5.

Never heard this band and this review means I probably never will but nicely done.

Thanks all. Glad you enjoyed it =)

More to come, hopefully.

And btw, passes for the PT gig (Mood I) are out - in case anyone's interested.

I'm a huge PT fan and this album disappointed me. Time Flies and Octane Twisted are the only songs worth listening to more than once.

Worse, PT will be playing every song from Disc 1 at Bombay. Quite a bummer.

Previous setlists - www.setlist.fm/setlists/porcupine-tree-63d6b2fb.html

So who's going? Venkatraman brothers? We expect a report for the main site, mkay?

Krishna Ravi wrote:

Worse, PT will be playing every song from Disc 1 at Bombay. Quite a bummer.

Previous setlists - www.setlist.fm/setlists/porcupine-tree-63d6b2fb.html

So fucking happy that I didn't already buy a ticket.

I just hope that they don't play much from The incident. I tried listening to the album twice and i couldn't get past 3 songs

Srikanth Panaman wrote:
So who's going? Venkatraman brothers? We expect a report for the main site, mkay?

Sure thing, would be nice to make it collaborative like the DR review.

Okay bitches. I'm done with my bit of the review. Who else wants to contribute. How do we do this?

google wave is how we do this. :|

Kay. Two people have sent theirs in, the others can send theirs in the next 12 hours. This goes up on the frontpage tomorrow.

Sending my input in the space of an hour

I woulda typed some shit but I'm not back in town till Sunday (and therefore no access to a comp for more than 5 mins).